Do flatlands. I dare you.

Though anyone who knows me knows that I love “Flatland: A Romance in Many Dimensions,” casting a book populated entirely by abstract concepts is not as simple a task as one might imagine. To be frank, it would probably be easier to cast Thomas the Tank Engine with The Brothers Karamazov (Percy is Pavel Smerdyakov obviously), but nevertheless I am obligated to give this novella’s diverse cast a fair, honest, and completely serious appraisal.

A. Square: Ryo Urawa. Representative of the everyman, both the Square and Urawa are narrative devices, vessels for the absurd. Both are chosen especially for a task that requires contact with what is considered supernatural but is actually an ordinary phenomenon.

A. Square’s Wife: The baby plesiosaur. Though this is another one-off character, the role as a passive receptor of misfortune and an entirely dependent creature was too perfect to let slip through my fingers.

Chromastities, leader of the Color Revolt: Ann. The Doom Tree arc is criminally underrepresented in general, a misfortune I hope to correct. Ann’s jealous and self-conscious nature is reflected by the color revolt’s leader, one who simply wanted an easy way to distinguish polygons from one another, both to make his own high-status presence known and secure his own place in the social order.

King of Lineland: Momoko. Some may have reservations about casting a ten-year-old girl as the monarch of a civilization, but her status as a frequent victim of the week due to her position as Chibiusa’s acquaintance mirrors the King as a victim of ignorance. The King never believes in a second dimension, but it is through no fault of his own that he is unaware of the strange happenings around him.

Pointland: The Dreamland Princess automaton. She appears as a villain of the week only once but in that time managed to cement her personality as one who would not compromise for her ideals, just as Pointland unyieldingly maintains exclusively the existence of the self like a Cartesian philosopher. Her singular line of thought is admirable, yet damning.

Pantocyclus, the High Circle: Kakeru, the psychotic astronomer from the S movie. I think this requires very little explanation.

The Sphere: Mimette. Clearly she possesses some greater insight into the earthly condition than she usually lets on, but occasionally we see that her abject superiority is clear. She appears only briefly in the lives of our protagonists, but what little exposure they received was enough to change their lives forever.

DO SAILOR EYRE!

The more of these I do, the more I remember how little I care for most of the characters in Victorian literature. I decided to correspond each location/stage of life Jane experiences with a season of Sailor Moon. Because this is where my life is at right now. This is how I voluntarily spend my free time. Enjoy.

Jane Eyre: Ami (“Though I am poor, obscure, plain, and little, I will punish you in the name of Thornfield Manor.”)

Rochester: Luna (often i cast her because of her role as a mentor rather than her abrasive judgmental personality; here she defensive because she is trying to atone for her mistakes of the past in the Silver Millennium by getting things right the second time around. And she is the only one with whom i can see Ami forming any kind of long term partnership. What a troubled soul)

Mrs. Reed: Beryl (needs no further justification than being the alpha bitch of season one)

Bessie Lee: Makoto (she sings songs and tells stories to Ami when she’s sad I don’t see what else you could want out of this)

Mr. Lloyd: Mamoru (a generically good guy who extols the merits of a solid education)

Georgiana Reed: Nephrite (is well aware that his hair is worthy of envy)

Eliza Reed: Zoisite (see above)

John Reed: Jadeite (i hate this kid. i hate him so much)

Helen: Diana (beautiful cinnamon roll too good for this world, too pure)

Mr. Brocklehurst: Prince Dimande (hypocrite who doesn’t believe in singular power unless it belongs to him; covers everything he owns in jewels and drapery)

Miss Temple: Usagi (deliverer of justice for Ami in the form of compassion, actual saint stand-in and positive female role model extravaganza)

Miss Scratcherd: Berthier (Ami’s literary foil and personalized antagonist)

Grace Poole: Pluto (literally the guardian of the past, charged with keeping Serenity from appearing)

Bertha: Queen Serenity (whose death and memory brings shame to Luna because she could not save her and her kingdom; possibly a spirit, possibly a corporeal entity, possibly a figment of everyone’s imagination)

Adele Varens: Hotaru (precocious child and Ami’s student)

Celine Varens: Professor Tomoe (epitome of poor parenting, probably an excellent opera singer)

Richard Mason: Zirconia (like a cut-rate preemptive version of Nehelenia)

Blanche Ingram: Nehelenia (brings back the memory of Queen Serenity like ripping off a band-aid; holds an ages-old grudge against the Moon family and won’t let anyone live in peace until revenge has been exacted)

St. John Rivers: Galaxia (extremely dedicated to her cause and is willing to take anyone she can down with her)

Diana and Mary Rivers: Rei and Minako (strong independent women who don’t need no men)

AND PRIDE AND PRISMS

I regret to inform you that the only correct Jane Austen/Sailor Moon pun is “Moon Pride and Prejudice.” I’m sorry.

Elizabeth: Usagi (exactly no one is more qualified as a heroine who specializes in snarky banter; basically the original strong independent woman in literature)

Darcy: Mamoru (if you ever find a more pretentious idiot please let me know because it will be a medical marvel)

Jane: Makoto (sweet sister)

Lydia: Minako (fun sister)

Mary: Ami (nerd sister)

Kitty: Rei (sister who does not get much development in-story but I am sure she is very interesting)

Mr Bennet: Artemis (he’s Minako’s dad already to be honest)

Mrs Bennet: Luna (also raised Usagi singlehandedly)

Charles Bingley: Motoki (let’s be honest anyone can look friendly and charismatic next to Mamoru)

Caroline Bingley: Beryl (weird crush on Endymion almost ruins everything for everyone once again)

George Wickham: Jadeite (misogynistic pile of trash; briefly seduces Minako before she learns to respect herself)

Catherine de Bourgh: Zoisite (scoffing sophisticatedly is a prized skill in this role)

Mr Collins: Umino (no one really knows if he’s hilarious or obnoxious)

Charlotte Lucas: Naru (that one friend of Elizabeth’s that everyone forgets about once the plot gets rolling)

Georgiana: Michiru (“She has great skill at playing the pianoforte.”)

damaskedredandwhite
replied to your post
“Add Frankenstein to the list”

I’m only disappointed you didn’t play on the painfully obvious homoerotic subtext in the frame story

It’s Sailor Moon. Everything is homoerotic subtext.

Add Frankenstein to the list

Why would you make me cast a book in which every character is the worst. (Except the monster, actually.)

Victor Frankenstein: Ami (really smart, really scared, and really easily paralyzed into inaction when she loses faith)

Frankenstein’s monster: Makoto (not because she is a monster, but quite to the contrary; everyone judges her based on appearance which leads to an abandonment complex, and sometimes that insecurity manifests itself in anger and sometimes rage baking isn’t enough and I just want to give her a big right now)

Robert Walton: Pluto (only exists for exposition; experiences the whole story without being able to interfere)

Elizabeth: Naru (epitome of the passive female in literature)

Alphonse: Mamoru (supportive dad figure; i am taken with the image of Alphonse’s speeches delivered from the top of a lamppost wearing a top hat)

Henry Clerval: Minako (oddly cheerful and fun for such a generally morose book; also if the Nurse Minako episode is any indication she is the perfect caretaker for the ill)

William: Hotaru (precious child and tool of revenge extraordinaire)

Justine: Haruka (blamed for Hotaru’s murder; probably took it like a champ)

Caroline: Usagi (literally, too good to live)

Felix and Agatha: Rei and Yuichiro (even if indirectly, the idea of Mako learning human interaction from them is cute enough for me)

De Lacey: Rei’s Grandpa (canonical old blind man; would probably hit on Mako no matter what)